difference between carburetor and fuel injection system

Difference between fuel injection and carburetor

After individual articles on the two important devices in an automobile engine; carburetor and fuel injection system, we realize throwing shade of the difference between them is essential.  The two components are different entirely, even in their working, shape, and design. The fact about the components is that the carburetor is seen on older automobile engines, while fuel injection is used on newer vehicles.

Well, drivers tend to enjoy the service fuel injection more than a carburetor. Knowing the difference between these engines, it has been highly debated among car users on which offers the best performance, either fuel injection or carburetor. Today you’ll get to know the difference between fuel injection and carburetor. You’ll also get to know their work and functions.

difference between carburetor and fuel injection system

Read: Understanding Fuel Injection Systems in automobile engines

Contents

Difference between carburetor and fuel injection system

Carburetor

A carburetor is a component used in a spark-ignition internal combustion engine to take in the exact air and fuel needed for the combustion. The part is known as the heart of automobile engines as it makes vehicles run smoothly and gives better horsepower. The component works well even at cold starting or running hot at high speed, letting the appropriate amount of fuel and air enter the combustion chamber.

The truth is fuel injection also does the same but in different ways as both feed fuel and air into the engine. The carburetor contains jets that push the fuel/air mixture into the combustion chambers. The amount of fuel the jets push depends on the amount of air that is pulled into the carburetor venture.

Because the carburetor works manually, the air-to-fuel ratio for each cylinder cannot be monitored. It wouldn’t be an issue if an individual carburetor is mounted for each cylinder. Thus, carburetors perform best when they are mounted individually to the cylinder to get the best fuel-to-air ratio.

The carburetor is much easier to install compared to the fuel injection system since there is no electrical component or return lines to the fuel tank. And it’s less expensive than that of an electronic fuel injection system. In addition, a carburetor lasts longer than a fuel injection system, making it useful in Motorsports. The limitation of a carburetor is that it causes the engine and surrounding components to dirty.

Read: Understanding a multi-point fuel injection system

Carburetor and Fuel injection

Versatility

By the 1990s, fuel injection had taken over and was becoming more and more popular in the automobile sector, replacing the carburetor. The carburetor has several drawbacks, starting with the fact that diesel vehicles cannot utilize it. On the other hand, there are mechanical and electronic fuel injection options available for both diesel and petrol automobiles.

Performance

The fuel flow to the cylinders can be continuously adjusted using a fuel injection system with an electronically controlled fuel induction, improving performance. A carburetor has trouble adjusting to changes in air pressure and fuel temperature as well as measuring the proper air-to-fuel ratio.

Fuel economy

Less fuel is wasted and greater fuel economy results from fuel injection systems that accurately provide the proper amount of gasoline and can adjust it based on several characteristics. A carburetor is unable to change the fuel ratio to suit the demands of the engine.

Maintenance

The only factor where fuel injection loses against a carburetor. It’s not too difficult to clean and repair a carburetor. Fuel injection systems need to be fixed by experts, or possibly expensively replaced.

Fuel injection system

The advancement of technology has brought about the fuel injection system. it’s the introduction of fuel in internal combustion engines as well as automotive engines, using an injector. The process was introduced to keep up with fuel emissions and fuel efficiency laws. Over some time, vehicle manufacturers have seen the great benefits of fuel injection, which is where the downfall of carburetors begins. Well, the system has become more popular for those car owners wanting the best performance in their engines.

The fuel injector system has small nozzles known as fuel injectors that are controlled electronically to atomize fuel under high pressure in the combustion chamber. The component contains valves that are capable of opening and closing many times per second. The fuel injection system is of two types; port fuel injection and direct injection. The port injection is common in automobiles, and direct injection is a new invention. It’s designed specifically for four or two-stroke engines.

Direct injection offers great benefits because the amount of fuel and air can be ideally released and then injected into the cylinder according to the engine load conditions. The system featured an ECU that calculates the information and constantly makes an adjustment. This is why direct fuel injection produces higher power output, greater fuel efficiency, and much lower emissions. The issue with this system is that the system is sophisticated and much more expensive compared to a carburetor. Its installation is more complicated. That’s, it’s complex as it uses an electrical component, and finally, custom cylinder head configuration.

Watch the video below to understand the workings of a fuel injection system better:

Now let’s see the difference between the fuel injection system and carburetor in tabular form:

S/N

Fuel injection system

Carburetor

1

New invention

First creation in automobiles

2

it works electronically

It works manually

3

Fuel is injected according to the engine load conditioner

Fuel to air ratio is not monitored

4

The injector valve can open and close multiple times per second

The air pulled into the carburetor venture determines the fuel the jets pushes.

5

Offers higher power output and greater fuel efficiency.

It runs smoothly and offers better horsepower

6

The installation is complicated due to its complexity.

Simpler installation due to its manual working.

Read: Lists of best diesel injector cleaner

So, which system is the best?

With the above elaboration made, it’s clear that a fuel injection system will be better for commercial vehicle owners as it gives lower fuel emissions. However, the cost of the components will make some drivers prefer vehicles with a carburetor. Both fuel injector and carburetor offer better horsepower, but the fuel injection can only deliver about 10 extra horsepower at peak.

This is the ability to constantly be tuning the intake fuel and air in each cylinder that’s adventurous to the performance. There is less vibration in an engine with a fuel injection system. You now see the difference between the fuel injection system and the carburetor. Now the best among the two depends on how and where you’re driving.

Read: Understanding an Indirect Injection System

Advantages of Carburetor and Fuel Injection

Carburetor

  • Carburetors are less expensive, easier to use, and simple to fix or replace.
    Users can fine-tune carburetors to meet their needs.
    Carburetors may be maintained or replaced without affecting the engine because they are not built into the engines.

Fuel injection

  • Cleaner, more effective combustion is made possible by an optimized air-fuel combination and atomization.
    a more responsive throttle.
    superior fuel economy and somewhat higher power compared to carbureted systems.
    They normally require minimal maintenance and do not malfunction.

Disadvantage of Carburetor and Fuel injection

Carburetors

  • Ineffective systems and an outdated design
    Most carburetors have a small lag, which makes their throttle response rather slow.
    Some parts, like the diaphragm, are susceptible to harm.
    Engine smoothness is impacted by the changing air/fuel combination.

Fuel Injection

  • significantly more costly than carburetors.
    can’t be fixed with basic tools and must be replaced, which costs money.
    can’t be customized unless you pay a lot of money for bespoke ECU mapping.

Related Article:

In conclusion, we’ve examined the difference between the two components that deal with fuel in automobiles; fuel injection and carburetor. We saw their working and various functions. I hope you enjoyed the reading, if so, kindly comment on your favorite section of this post, and don’t forget to share with other technical students. You can also check around for another informative article. Thanks!


Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *