Should I Repair or replace my old car?

Your car broke down, and you’re debating” Should I repair or replace my old car, facing a substantial repair charge? You’ve had this happen before, and investing more money in an outdated machine is becoming old. It would be lovely to have a new car, but is that the best choice?

Your vehicle will probably need significant repairs sooner or later, whether that’s because of aging, a significant collision, failing parts, or ordinary wear and tear. To decide whether to sell or fix your car, you must carefully weigh the benefits and drawbacks. Thus, in this article, we’ll be discussing” Should I repair or replace my old car”

Should I Repair or repair my old car

So, let’s dive in!


Should I Repair or replace my old car?

Repairing my old car

Even if you’ve taken good care of your vehicle, some costly repairs are sometimes necessary because of excessive wear or the passage of time. Electrical components stop operating, metal on rotors warps or become too thin, and rubber belts and hoses dry out and fracture. Axle boots, belts, and brake rotors are examples of wear-and-tear components that eventually require replacement. On high-mileage autos, the timing belt has long been a costly component. It needs to be changed every 100,000 miles on various vehicles.

The water pump and other drive belts in the automobile should be replaced at this point, according to service advisors at the dealership. The price of this “timing belt package” ranges from $600 to $1,000. This kind of repair first appears between 90,000 and 120,000 kilometers.

Benefits of repairing an old car

An automobile that requires extensive repairs can be a real pain. It could even seem that getting a brand-new car would be the perfect solution to all of your issues. Don’t give the keys to anyone just yet, though.

Sometimes it makes more financial sense to pay for repairs rather than the up-front price of a new car. Here are some reasons why making repairs might be the better choice for you:

  • It’s cheaper
  • It’s less time consuming
  • It may hold sentimental value
It’s cheaper

Even if you need pricey repairs like rebuilt gearboxes or engine work, it might not be as expensive as buying a brand-new vehicle. For instance, a new transmission might run you between $3,500 and $5,000. Even though this repair will cost a lot of money, it won’t cost as much as buying a new car.

While buying a new automobile could involve additional fees, having your car repaired simply requires one charge. Think about increased insurance costs, monthly auto payments, and registration fees.

It’s less time consuming

It takes time to research and buy a new automobile. Your automobile probably won’t be out of operation for more than a few days, even if it requires significant repairs. Similar to that, fixing your car eliminates the need for you to spend time marketing or selling it.

It may hold sentimental value

There could be sentimental value in your vintage car. If you’re anything like us, you take pride in your car. Sometimes the sentimental value of an automobile you’ve had for a while is sufficient to justify fixing it.

Extend the Life of Your Car

There are steps you can do to prevent or avoid expensive repairs if you are not yet forced to decide whether to fix up or trade-in your car.

  • Get your new automobile serviced at the recommended intervals to prevent issues and breakdowns. To find out the suggested service intervals for your vehicle, consult our maintenance guide. The parts that frequently fail require particular attention when maintaining a considerably older vehicle. As a less expensive option to a dealership repair center, we advise finding a reputable, trustworthy local mechanic.
  • Consult message boards and forums for your car’s make and model if you have problems with it and are unsure whether they are going to get worse. This path has likely been traveled previously by others. They can give you a sneak peek at the issues that will arise as your car ages.

Replacing my old car

Is it better to replace an old car than to try to fix it? There are good reasons to think about replacing your car even if it’s usually more cost-effective to fix it.


  • Benefits
  • Reliability
  • New car model and features
  • Warranty
  • Safety

Sometimes, newer cars are more dependable. If you buy a new automobile, you won’t have to worry about the smallest noises it makes or as frequently taking it to the mechanic. A new car might be well worth the price just for the peace of mind it provides.

New car model and features

You might be able to upgrade to a newer model of car. Your present vehicle can be a gas guzzler. It might also be missing features seen in more recent models. Anyhow, the money you make from selling your old automobile might be used as a down payment for a better choice.


There may be new car benefits available. An inducement to buy a new car is frequently free maintenance and warranties. These benefits not only increase your sense of security but also may enable you to make financial adjustments should something unexpectedly go wrong.


It’s possible that a new car is safer than your old one. Modern accessories and safety technology are frequently standard equipment in newer vehicles. You can drive more safely by utilizing cutting-edge safety technologies like blind-spot recognition and automated emergency braking.

The right time to replace a car

Here are a few situations where we might decide to purchase a different car:

  • The cost of the repairs is hard to keep up with, and they are happening more frequently.
  • You frequently become stranded by the car, which could put you in danger or cause you to be late for work.
  • The cost of the repair will be greater than half the car’s value.
  • Although you had already made plans to purchase a new vehicle, your mechanic informs you that your existing vehicle needs significant repair. Hold off and leave it in the hands of the next owner. Just be honest when the time comes to sell.


On when to fix a car and when to buy a new one, everyone appears to have an opinion. However, you are the best person to judge your needs and the history of your car, so just use these suggestions as a general reference. A new automobile purchase could seem like the simple solution to a hefty repair expense, but depending on your situation, it might not be the wisest financial move.

On the other hand, driving an automobile that is on the verge of irrelevance can keep you up at night. Instead, then waiting for the automobile to break down at the worst possible time, it’s best to sell it on your terms.

If you decide while the automobile is still somewhat valuable, you can sell it or trade it in and use the proceeds as a down payment for your future vehicle. A new car can be within your reach if you can also take advantage of the discounts and rebates that are now being provided on new cars. Additionally, the peace of mind that a new car may provide is difficult to value.

Related Article


Should you repair the old car?

If your car needs substantial repairs, is more than ten years old, or has more than 150,000 miles on it (which, if you’re using average driving mileage, is basically the same), the auto website CarX advises replacing it.

How do I decide to replace or repair it?

Find out the cost of the repair, compare it to the value of your automobile, and the amount you would have to spend to drive off the lot with a replacement to come up with the answer. You can determine more clearly whether doing additional repairs is a lost investment by looking at all these numbers.

Why should you replace an old car?

  • Regularly replace the oil and oil filter.
  • Keep all fluids filled to the proper level.
  • Change the spark plugs.
  • Change the coolant.
  • Examine the brake fluid.
  • Rotate your tires according to the manufacturer’s recommendations.
  • Every month and before long travels, check the tire pressure in all your tires.

Is it worth replacing my car?

Another general rule is to think about replacing your automobile if annual repair costs exceed 10% of the cost of the new vehicle you’re considering. Include the cost of insurance. Do your research and determine the annual insurance cost difference between a new and an old car.

Is it worth it to replace the suspension?

It’s crucial for driving safety to replace your shocks and struts when they become worn out in order to avoid harming other parts of your car, such as the tires and suspension. Various safety features are included in today’s cars to help with control, stability, and accident prevention.

Should I keep a 20-year-old car?

The vehicle’s reliability does depend on how many miles have been driven on it. Any car shouldn’t be driven past the mid-to late-1990s since parts become more difficult to come by after that point.

Is it worth replacing a clutch?

Your clutch should last for about 60,000 miles, but you should schedule a clutch replacement as soon as you notice a burning smell, difficulties shifting, a higher biting point than typical, or a terrible sound when shifting.

Is fixing the rust on a car worth it?

It’s best to just move on unless you want to take a chance on a possibly expensive repair that could end up costing more than the car is worth plus the prospect of failing a safety inspection.

Does rust ruin an engine?

Rust in your engine compartment should be taken very seriously because it can damage pistons and lead to accelerated wear and tear. In addition, rust slowly degrades the metal parts of your engine compartment.

Can a rusted chassis be repaired?

Surface rust that develops on or around the tires can usually be repaired. However, it could be very impossible to restore a car if rust starts to seep through the panels. Of course, each historic car should be assessed individually.

That’s all for this article where we discussed the topic “Should I Repair or replace my old car?”. Hope it was helpful, if so, kindly share. Thanks for reading.

Write A Comment